Еще один отзыв

[hope1972]

Негативный, пришелдший ко мне через рассылку. Абсолютно совпадающий с моим мнением. Правда, тут уже порезанно как-то странно и кто-то отвечает на вопросы. Но все равно, даже с ответами вопросы понятны.



be honest, I was disappointed. This movie could have had so
much, but (like 1 and 2) was just a bunch of special effects linking
together poor acting and poor writing(Hayden Christensen as the evil
Vader? Totally unbelievable)

Evil Vader? No twisted hot heated full of himself Vader..I think he pulled
that off perfectly. If he had been the cool calm and collected Evil Lord
Vader he would have left that planet and immediately killed the Emperor.


Also, there were several glaring errors as
far as continuity goes. In New Hope, how come Obi-Wan doesnt
remember R2? In Return of the Jedi, why does Obi Wan say "When your
father left, he didn't know your mother was pregnant. ..

Well, he didn't know she gave birth... they buried her like she was still
pregnant..hence the large belly she had her hands folded upon. Because Sith
Lords are so focused on themselves he didn't bother to search either..Not
exactly father of the Year award material> eh?
The Emperor told him HE killer her in his angry rage but that wasn't true
and he even says She was ALIVE I know it...right before he busted everything to
hell and back. Also didn't the Emp look like he was feeding off his power?
Even the all powerful Emp didn't know who Luke was until after Obiwan
died..it makes me think he was helping hide Luke in a totally unique way.

R2 didn't belong to him. R2 was a production line droid. I don't think the
characters would have thought so intimately about the "droids" like we do.

If Obiwan had of told Luke hey..your dad's alive..and guess what you have
sister...Luke would have run headlong straight into the Emperor's hands.
Because LUKE not VADER brought balance to the force.


Also, Leia
(when refering to her mother) says "She was very beautiful. Kind,
but...sad." Is this in reference to Padme?? or to Mrs. Organa. Its
these little factual errors that turn me off from this movie.


Plus,
the entire Wookie fight scene seemed to be only a lame way to get
Chewabacca included in the movie.

Comments

[mercantile.livejournal.com]

I still believe that it was Vader who brought the balance to the Force. Instead of two hiding siths and an army of Jedi we now have Sidius-Vader and Yoda-Obi Wan. And also indirectly, when the balance was sort of maintained through Luke when the dark lords including Vader followed Yoda and others.

[hope1972.livejournal.com]

Yeah! Kill all of the Jedi, leave just two of them alive and then you have two Sith versus two Jedi. Surely it`s a balance! :))))) Some balance!
Then Luke came of age.... and here you are - no Sith at all:)))
Everything is in order...

[mercantile.livejournal.com]

Yoda said that the prophecy could be misread, implying that "bringing the balance" doesn't mean defeating all the Siths.

Я считаю, что ситхи - не плохие. См. мои впечатления в разделе о джедаях. Нет причин считать их "абсолютным злом". Так же борются за власть, как и все. Что значит "темная сторона"? Та, которая не "светлая"? И Дуку, и Палпатин были бы вполне достойными гражданами, если бы Джедаи не пытались от них избавиться.

[hope1972.livejournal.com]

Ты прав - баланс - не означает убить всех ситхов. Кстати, это был бы не баланс как раз! Я просто прикололась выше.
А вопрос темного-светлого - вопрос философский, размышлять долго можно :)